Katharine McPhee isn’t the only one working this graphic look — we keep seeing white shoes paired with opaque black tights on a lot of red carpets. Is it the mod influence that’s sweeping through fashion, or is it a flagrant flaunting of the old rules about wearing white shoes after Labor Day? We’re all about getting the maximum wear out of everything in our closets, but we have to admit that we’re not loving this look. Tell us: Do you like black tights with white shoes? Is this a look you would wear?
See more debatable fashion trends in our Would You Wear It? gallery poll.