We already pondered whether or not going vampy was Mandy Moore‘s best look — but just because something does or does not work on a star doesn’t mean that it can’t work for us. Deep red lips are a hot trend for fall, but would you wear a dark color like that? Tell us: Would you wear Mandy’s deep red lipstick? Or are you sticking to neutral and bright tones for fall?
Want your answer to appear in print? To have your comment considered for the next issue of PEOPLE’s StyleWatch, please INCLUDE your first name and last initial, your age and your hometown/state.