Super-sheer fabrics, plunging necklines, micro-minis—we’ve seen all sorts of barely-there pieces pop up on daring celebs! And Fergie, no stranger to bold looks, added a new one to her eclectic, rocker mix while vacationing in St. Barts over the New Year’s holiday: a T-shirt filled with holes! A tropical getaway might make the most sense for such a revealing shirt, but we wonder—is it too over the top, even for a tropical island? Or is it a cool, artsy take on a white T-shirt? We want to know what you think — your opinion may just appear in the next issue of PEOPLE StyleWatch! Tell us: Would you wear Fergie’s ripped-up T-shirt? Vote below!