Ever wonder what’s the secret to Brooke Shield’s flawless complexion or Niki Taylor’s glossy smile? Stars like Selena Gomez, Valerie Bertinelli, Shields, Taylor and more recently dished to PEOPLE about their must-have beauty items. What they revealed may surprise you –- running the gamut from multi-purpose lotions and sunscreens to eyelash curlers. “There’s this product called Egyptian Magic—you can put it on cuts, you can put it on your hair, you can put it on your eyes,” said Shields. What item tops Gomez’ beauty arsenal? “The beauty accessory I can’t live without is probably M.A.C concealer,” said the Wizards of Waverly Place star. Covermodel Taylor is also a M.A.C fan, getting specific about her fave Dazzleglass lip product. “It’s the M.A.C lipstick I have on right now. It’s super, super sticky and it’s called Baby Sparks.” Meanwhile, Bertinelli points to Cindy Crawford’s Meaningful Beauty line to stay looking flawless. “I love it!” beamed the Jenny Craig spokesmodel. Tell us: What’s your beauty must-have?