1 of 39
JANUARY VS. COCO
When you’re on mom duty like the , you wear this nautical striped Rachel Zoe jacket with skinnies and boots. When you’re on model duty like Coco, you totally wear it with the matching short-shorts.
2 of 39
ASHLEY VS. JESSICA
We made a shirt very similar to and at a birthday party in eighth grade. All you need is a glue gun and some gems from the craft store, or you can spend $158 on their Current Elliot x Revolve topper.
3 of 39
ASHLEY VS. BELLA
Sure, Ashley is wearing the “Hanna” dress from Aeropostale’s Pretty Little Liars collection. (That’s her character.) But Bella brings her own brand of cool to the asymmetrical design.
4 of 39
JENNIFER VS. CHLOË
Apparently all you need to pull off this multicolor Christopher Kane mini are some black heels and a bold attitude. Oh yeah, and a supersize bank account.
5 of 39
EMMA VS. OLIVIA
Did you just get the sudden urge to throw on your black moto jacket with a cute pair of jeans and some fun shoes so you can post an #OOTD Insta? Staring at the actresses’ Marté x Dani Stahl for Calypso topper will do that.
6 of 39
MICHELLE VS. CAT
What we do know: They’re both British, both have super-shiny hair and both own this tweed Ella Moss topper. What we don’t know: Who will win this tough-to-call faceoff.
7 of 39
PRIYANKA VS. NAOMI
This Alexander McQueen gown is hanging in our “virtual closet’ ” (in other words, pinned on Pinterest). But the Guess model and actress have the stunner in their real closets. Le sigh.
8 of 39
KARINA VS. DARBY
There’s the sexy way to wear this printed Alexa von Canisius skirt – with a leather embellished bustier top and platform peep-toes as seen on the Dancing With the Stars pro – and the the sweet way to wear it – with a high-neck silk blouse and classic pumps on the Scandal actress.
9 of 39
GWYNETH VS. GISELE
With winter storm Janus hitting hard, we wish we had and cozy FAY parka. We also wish we had their hair, their bodies and their lives in general, but that’s another topic for another time.
10 of 39
MICHELLE VS. DUCHESS CATHERINE
The only thing that would make us happier than the duo’s velvet J Brand pants showdown is if the nabbed a guest role on Downton Abbey. Are you listening, Julian Fellowes?
11 of 39
TINA VS. SOLANGE
Did Tina swipe this Mason by Michelle Mason coat from her daughter’s closet? Unclear. Did Solange inherit her fierce attitude and style sense from her mom? Absolutely.
12 of 39
MARIA VS. RIHANNA
You can wear this white Torn by Ronny Kobo sweater dress with a pair of simple pumps like Maria, or you can wear it with all the accessories in your closet like .
13 of 39
LINDSAY VS. LALA
The last time we shopped a velvet turtleneck dress was in 1997 at Limited Too. But and Lala bring back the trend in this printed Balmain design.
14 of 39
JAIME VS. JANUARY
This camel Leon Max coat is so chic that it could make a pair of sweatpants and flip-flops look sophisticated. But Jaime and know better, throwing their toppers over jeans and boots instead.
15 of 39
OLIVIA VS. JENNIFER
Perfect hair. Perfect skin. Perfect body. That’s all you need to pull off this bright Victoria Beckham halter. NBD. Well NBD if you’re this actress or the , who both have all three.
16 of 39
BELLA VS. LUCY
Pair this fit-and-flare Paper London skirt with a basic tee? Totally out of the question for Bella and Lucy, who choose midriff-flaunting and bra-baring tops, respectively.
17 of 39
ZOË VS. JESSICA
It might be best to play a game of “Eenie, Meenie, Miney, Mo” when voting on this one. Because both and look like dynamite (sorry, we had to) in their “BOOM”-printed 3.1 Phillip Lim for Target sweatshirts.
18 of 39
MIRANDA VS. KIM
You can take the DIY approach and distress a pair of old jeans in your closet with some scissors and sandpaper. Or you can spend more than two grand for these chain-embellished Saint Laurent bottoms like the and did.
19 of 39
ASHLEY VS. VANESSA
Unfortunately, this embroidered Free People military jacket is not warm enough for the Polar Vortex currently freezing half the country, but why not get it anyway and stash it away for spring?
20 of 39
ROSIE VS. JENNIFER
The keys to pulling off this Balmain mini: a killer bod, black ankle boots and a fierce pose. And clearly the supermodel and nail all three.
21 of 39
22 of 39
PETA VS. JANA
Does this Mikael D gown, with its sexy sheer underlay, come with instructions on how to do the perfect hip-popped-sultry-stare pose as demonstrated by the Dancing with the Stars pro and country singer?
23 of 39
JESSICA VS. CARA
It takes a bold woman to wear this busy floral MinkPink sweatshirt. It takes an even bolder woman to wear the top with the coordinating printed pants.
24 of 39
CELINE VS. SELENA
Some pieces of apparel work just as well on as they do on . You know, like bootcut jeans, cardigans and apparently, lacy breast-baring Atelier Versace dresses.
25 of 39
KIERNAN VS. ALEXA
We envy both of these ladies’ styles so it makes sense that they each own this collared black-and-red checked dress. And it seems appropriate that the younger star goes for a longer hemline and opaque tights, while the elder shows a lot of leg.
26 of 39
ASHLEY VS. CIARA
Even the captain of the high school football team couldn’t pull off a python varsity jacket. But these two stars make the fancy $1,015 Skingraft topper work with sexy, skin-baring apparel.
27 of 39
ALESSANDRA VS. JOURDAN
A gown so plunging that it almost shows your belly button is to supermodels as a basic LBD is to the rest of us: no big deal. Which is probably why Alessandra and Jourdan look so comfortable in this Hugo Boss design.
28 of 39
KOURTNEY VS. JESSICA
If the question were, Who layers her Rails flannel better?, would be the clear winner. But we’re more interested in who looks cooler in the plaid button-down.
29 of 39
DITA VS. SARAH
Both the burlesque queen and actress look amazing in this low-cut Carolina Herrera gown. So you’re going to have to make this decision based on which version of the dress you like best – the cream floral print or the electric pink.
30 of 39
KARLIE VS. MARIA
We’ll give you a minute to register for that kickboxing class online. Back? Good, now vote for one of these toned beauties (with matching haircuts!) in the same white KaufmanFranco mini.
31 of 39
ADRIANA VS. SANDRA
This model may not have an Oscar on her mantel. And this may not have a pair of feathered wings in her dresser. But they both have this Carolina Herrera dress hanging in their closets.
32 of 39
NICOLE VS. JOAN
It’s no surprise our trendsetter of the year pairs her bold floral Givenchy moto jacket with an even bolder black-and-white striped top, while the supermodel plays it safer and keeps the rest of her outfit neutral.
33 of 39
ALICIA VS. MICHELLE
This Stella McCartney gown gets around more than any other dress in Hollywood (, Brooklyn Decker and Edie Falco have all worn it). But the latest two stars to slip into the halter are the in yellow and the Downton Abbey star in black.
34 of 39
KAT VS. CARA
No, we’re not asking you to weigh in on who best uses double-sided tape? (They’re both clearly very adept at that.) We just want to know which actress looks hottest in her plunging Versace jumpsuit.
35 of 39
CHERYL VS. JESSICA
When you’re wearing a dizzying jailbird-stripe top like this Malene Birger one, it’s probably best to follow Cheryl and lead and keep the pants simple.
36 of 39
37 of 39
BELLA VS. KACEY
Living room curtains come in packs of two so we suppose we shouldn’t be surprised to see this curtain-inspired Blumarine dress twice. Of course, both stars manage to look goddesslike in the floral designs.
38 of 39
JENNA VS. KAT
Bold move: wearing a geometric-print Ted Baker London shorts suit. (See: Jenna.) Bolder move: wearing the same metallic geometric print short suits sans shirt. (That would be Kat.)
39 of 39
ZENDAYA VS. OLIVIA
When you’re sporting a voluminous white spotted tulle skirt like this Chloé one, your shoes need to be pretty fabulous to get noticed. These ladies clearly got the fancy footwear message (not to mention the memo about the black tops).
We Tried It: L.A.-Based The Now, a Massage Boutique
The Pro Files: Get to Know Celeb Makeup Artist Pati Dubroff
The History of the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Look
Kim Kardashian Pushes Swimwear Boundaries by Not Wearing Swimwear at All