WATCH AND SHOP: Where Has This Jewelry Armoire Been All Our Lives?
1 of 65
KATIE VS. JESSICA
Not only do both actresses have the same Isabel Marant leather jackets, but they also are apparently both on their way to audition for a ’90s rock music video. What a coincidence!
2 of 65
ASHLEY VS. STACY
Can you spot the subtle difference between Rebecca Minkoff ensemble and Stacy’s? Hint: One’s a dress and one isn’t.
3 of 65
LAUREN VS. MARIA
It makes sense that two of the L.A. ladies whose style we most covet are wearing a dress by a designer whose creations we covet. They’re in versions of the same Kate Spade New York “Rainey.
4 of 65
HILARY VS. KATHARINE
styles her draped Lovers + Friends skirt in a Hollywood way (bustier, layered necklaces, booties), while Katharine gives it a Coachella feel (button-up, funky sandals, shades, ombré bob).
5 of 65
LUCY VS. OLGA
You know what they say: If you love it, buy it in two colors. Well, if we had enough cash to get two Roland Mouret gowns, the shades we’d pick would be these, black and emerald.
6 of 65
SELENA VS. KATY
Here s a sentence we never thought we’d type: Look how versatile this floral Dolce & Gabbana bustier is! The wears hers with nude heels and a pencil skirt, but goes all out and adds a Dali-print mini and chunky white heels.
7 of 65
KATIE VS. RIHANNA
On , Current/Elliott’s $198 “Perfect Shirt” is a fun, casual beach coverup. On , though, the same piece somehow becomes edgy and fashion-forward.
8 of 65
JAMIE VS. EMMY
Thanks, ladies, for showing us two adorable ways to wear a striped spring dress. Now all that’s left to do is vote and then, of course, click to buy the knit style, $79.90, from Express.
9 of 65
ALEXA VS. CHLOË
Half of the editors here prefer this Simon Rocha number in black on Alexa with funky heels, but the rest of us like it in lemon yellow on Chloë, with her glam ankle-strap pumps. So, we need you to help break the tie.
10 of 65
OLIVIA VS. NICKY
Olivia gives her super-girlie Valentino dress some edge with studded heels and an equally sharp bracelet, while Nicky embraces the sweetness of the design with feminine peep-toes and milkmaid braids.
11 of 65
ASHLEY VS. KHLOé
The Twilight wears her Antonio Berardi dress with a ladylike below-the-knee hem and classic pumps, while the youngest gives hers a sexy makeover, shortening it and adding eye-catching heels.
12 of 65
JULIANNE VS. JULIANNE
It’s a battle of the , who both select the JET by John Eshaya leather-sleeved army jacket. They even style the topper similarly: with ombré shades and black skinnies.
13 of 65
MISCHA VS. VANESSA
Considering crop tops are so huge for spring, we suppose we shouldn’t be so surprised that these two stars have the same darling lace Katharine Kidd ensemble.
14 of 65
AMANDA VS. MINDY
Two funny ladies, one interesting dress. The actresses step out the same Saint Laurent baby-doll silhouette with a dotted yoke, though the shoe choices couldn’t be more different.
15 of 65
SARAH VS. MORENA
Who looks sweeter in this bow-accented Paule Ka dress: the Modern Family star with her loose waves and silver platforms, or the Homeland actress, in her updo and pumps?
16 of 65
LAUREN VS. KELLY
On , this Camilla and Marc jumpsuit is sweet and slightly preppy. On Kelly, however, it takes on a very “Ozzy tribute” vibe.
17 of 65
JADA VS. ADRIANA
Can you guess which star is wearing her Alberta Ferretti gown the intended way and who has it on backwards? This is a tricky one, but Jada’s wearing hers correctly. (Though we have to admit Adriana’s 180º rotation works too.)
18 of 65
EMMY VS. HILARY
This might be the last jacket faceoff you see for a while (Mother Nature willing), so be sure to really soak in the chic, military-inspired Gerard Darel peacoat Emmy and Hilary are wearing.
19 of 65
KATE VS. SHAY
We can either envy these two stars for getting their hands on the Derek Lam for Kohl’s collection before it hits stores on April 5, or we can admire them for loving a bargain (it’s only $70!) as much as we do.
20 of 65
MIREILLE VS. EVA
The Killing’s star looks almost angelic in her slashed and sequined white Emilio Pucci gown, but in black, on this number is sexy and daring.
21 of 65
FREIDA VS. LEA
The two brunette beauties are like a valentine to Valentino, each in their red and pink versions of the same strapless, ruffled gown.
22 of 65
JESSICA VS. ANNE
A lesson in wearing cozy crochet sweaters brought to you by and (in the Paper Denim & Cloth “Lexington): Do it casually by adding colored jeans, or dress up the top by layering it over a maxi dress.
23 of 65
ASHLEY VS. JESSICA
Two starlets, two colors, but only one dress can win this tough-to-call Fashion Faceoff. Do you prefer neon version of this $398 RVN number or Jessica’s cool blue-and-white look?
24 of 65
KYLIE VS. WILLA
Both stars get fringe benefits from this yellow Stella McCartney brocade dress, but while Kylie keeps her accessories low-key, Willa opts for attention-getting ivory add-ons.
25 of 65
ANNASOPHIA VS. ZENDAYA
The Carrie Diaries star wears this Alice + Olivia “Lollie” dress ($795 here) on set, giving it an ’80s vibe with a bright belt and jean jacket. But Disney tween Zendaya prefers a more 2013 feel, sporting it with a sweater and chunky brown sandals.
26 of 65
LOUISE VS. KHLOé
Red, white and sexy all over should be the motto for this striped Robert Rodriguez tube dress. Both ladies accessorize with white heels, but Louise opts for a more classic route with pumps, and goes for statement Giuseppe Zanotti sandals.
27 of 65
OLIVIA VS. ANNE
The actresses take a ride on the wild side in these bicycle-print Paige Denim jeans. Olivia opts for electric blue Reeboks and a graphic American Eagle tank to complete her look, while pairs her red bottoms with a Topshop Nasa tee and Ash high-top sneakers.
28 of 65
EMMY VS. PIPPA
Emmy adds pops of color to this summer-friendly Tabitha Webb blossom shift dress with a cherry red satchel and mint strappy sandals, while keeps her accessories neutral.
29 of 65
KEIRA VS. KRISTEN
and show us two very different ways to wear the same Balenciaga quilted leather jacket – the flirty-meets-edgy way over a flowy frock, and the hipster way with skinnies, a tee and Chucks.
30 of 65
ALESSANDRA VS. PIPER
Even though 83 percent of you dubbed this Broadway curtains dress a hot mess, that’s not stopping Hollywood from sporting the look. Both Alessandra and Piper wear the Barbara Bui frock with black strappy sandals and a black clutch, keeping the debate wide open.
31 of 65
KATHARINE VS. COBIE
The one requirement for wearing this Theyskens’ Theory gown: superhot cleavage, which and Cobie have covered (or rather, uncovered). And apparently the one accessory they feel the dress calls for: ankle-strap heels.
32 of 65
JESSICA VS. OLIVIA
How could we ever play favorites with two of our favorite street-style stars?! We wouldn’t dream of it, which is why we’re asking you to weigh in on the floral Tibi blazer, worn with skinny jeans, a white tee and sandals by the and with Zara culottes, layered tops and black oxfords by the socialite.
33 of 65
GWYNETH VS. LENA VS. MILEY
We can’t think of any possible situation in which we’d mention , Lena and in the same sentence besides this one: They’ve all braved the same black-and-white Valentino jumpsuit.
34 of 65
JESSICA VS. EVA
Jessica adds some color to the sheer-sleeved Izmaylova LBD with an orange clutch and matching ankle-strap sandals, while goes for monochromatic with black peep-toe booties.
35 of 65
HEATHER VS. CANDACE
Nobody could compete with DJ Tanner’s unique style, but Heather takes on the actress who played her with this leather Alice + Olivia dress.
36 of 65
37 of 65
CARLY VS. SELITA
Sure, the stars are wearing the same skirt and tee combo by Tsemaye Binitie, but Carly gives the look a slightly less feminine, more rock-and-roll feel by removing the skirt’s second sheer overlay.
38 of 65
EMMY VS. KRYSTEN
The actresses channel their inner pinup girls (and show their patriotism) with the exact same look – a navy polka-dot Stop Staring! dress, red pumps and matching red lips. But who is the queen of this retro ensemble? Good luck deciding!
39 of 65
ZOË VS. ALESSANDRA
When we run errands, we’re usually in yoga pants and a schlubby T-shirt. But not in Hollywood! Both and Alessandra go casual (and still manage to look hella chic) in the same paisley-print Ella Moss pants. The Star Trek Into Darkness star tops her bottoms with a white tee, while the Victoria’s Secret Angel adds a coordinating lavender tee and purple-and-gray scarf.
40 of 65
CHELSEA VS. VANESSA
These Disney alums share a mutual love for bold color and lots of sequins. Case in point, this electric yellow Alice + Olivia by Stacy Bendet dress. Chelsea tones down the shine with nude pumps, while adds even more sparkle with gold sandals.
41 of 65
GABRIELLE VS. JULIANNE
Who’s afraid of dangerously low necklines and fashion-forward onesies? Not these ladies. They both pair the red Bec & Bridge number with metallic sandals – and even show it off with the same stance!
42 of 65
ALESSANDRA VS. OLIVIA
This Lovers + Friends dress has been spotted in the StyleWatch fashion closet, and we all keep walking by it longingly. Alessandra got her hands on one (lucky) and wears it with chic flats, while Olivia opts for neutral wedges.
43 of 65
RIHANNA VS. KANYE
The fact that and are in a Fashion Faceoff isn’t even the most shocking part; it’s that they both style their Givenchy Rottweiler tees from the same collection strangely similarly: tucked into leather bottoms and under open jackets.
44 of 65
DIANE VS. MOLLIE
From punk to pretty: Diane edges up her printed Marni mini with a black belt, moto boots and an oversize satchel. But The Saturdays singer goes girlie by adding a pop of color via neon peep-toes.
45 of 65
AMANDA VS. KATY
Moto jackets are practically mandatory in Hollywood, so it’s no surprise and have the same AllSaints one. Amanda wears hers over a girlie Saint Laurent dress, and Katy is all rocker, pairing it with a graphic tee and leather pants.
46 of 65
HEIDI VS. KATE
The official uniform for the Hot Blonde Moms Club must be this 291 graphic pullover, which they each love to wear with jeans.
47 of 65
ALLISON VS. JENNIFER
We always thought Marnie was more of a Monica, but the Girls star wears the same Christian Dior tuxedo-style bustier as the Friends selected, even styling it similarly with black bottoms and classic pumps.
48 of 65
GWEN VS. KOURTNEY
Checkmates! and are two of the few stars edgy and fashion-forward enough to pull off this Kelly Wearstler trench, which they both pair with black leggings, boots and sunnies.
49 of 65
ANNASOPHIA VS. KRYSTEN
Two fairy nymphs? No, it’s two Hollywood stars in white, feathery, ethereal Alice + Olivia by Stacey Bendet dresses. The Carrie Diaries actress keeps the look ladylike with silver pumps, while Krysten mixes it up with black peep-toes and a laser-cut clutch.
50 of 65
51 of 65
DEMI VS. NICOLE
The and the are both off (or should we say on?) the chain in matching chain-embellished Saint Laurent minis, seen here in black and white.
52 of 65
JESSICA VS. REESE
Two moms in jeans, but no mom jeans in sight. pairs her distressed Black Orchid skinnies with a loose white button-down, while goes for a denim-on-denim look with a chambray shirt.
53 of 65
HAYDEN VS. JENNA
We want to challenge these celebs to an on-screen sing-off, but we’ll settle for the Nashville and the Glee actress battling it out in a Fashion Faceoff in their pleated, striped dresses by Jonathan Simkhai.
54 of 65
MARIA VS. GIULIANA
These two don’t just compete for viewers; the TV hosts also compete here for your votes. They each choose this floral dress by The Hellers, but Maria adds green sandals, quite different from the polished nude pumps Giuliana picks.
55 of 65
ALYSON VS. KOURTNEY
The actress keeps up with the in this double-breasted Skaist Taylor blazer, but Alyson stops there, forgoing the matching shorts.
56 of 65
GWEN VS. RIHANNA
It appears that there is a uniform for international singing superstars with rock-hard abs: this white Balmain crop top and a pair of leather trousers. The main difference between and ensembles? The voluminousness of their Balmain bottoms.
57 of 65
ASHLEY VS. VANESSA
We shop our friends closets, so why shouldn’t celebs? Or perhaps and both love the Big Star muscle tee so much that they each got their own.
58 of 65
SELENA VS. KATE
What it takes to successfully pull off a pair of shiny black leather pants, like these Plein Sud ones: a killer body, loads of confidence and apparently, one crazy cool pair of shoes. Luckily, the and the fulfill all those requirements.
59 of 65
HEATHER VS. JESSICA
Looking to splurge on a bachelorette party dress? Take a cue from these actresses and get your body-con on in this geometric-printed RVN dress. The only question is what shoes to wear: coordinating strappy platforms like Heather’s or basic black peep-toes like Jessica’s?
60 of 65
LO VS. MIRANDA
We never thought an L.A. socialite and a country queen would step out in the exact same dress. But Lo and prove anything is possible in this floral Shoshanna frock. Lo keeps it California chic with barely there sandals, while Miranda goes big (as opposed to home) with a pair of neon platforms.
61 of 65
HEIDI VS. SELENA
This neon-accented Atelier Versace gown caught the eyes of (in Pepto pink) and (in white), but the style similarities don’t end there: They’re both wearing Jimmy Choo Lance sandals.
62 of 65
AMANDA VS. MINKA
To tuck or not to tuck? That is the question, StyleWatchers. lets her white Bella Dahl button-down (get it in our favorite shades here!) hang loose with a pair of blue skinnies, while Minka keeps her shirttails under wraps.
63 of 65
MALIN VS. KHLOé
Do you think the actress and the had to get certified in order to wear this SCUBA-ready T by Alexander Wang mini made of wetsuit material? And do you prefer it with pumps or studded booties or flippers?
64 of 65
CHRISTINA VS. JENNIFER
With everyone wearing jumpsuits, it was only a matter of time before a onesie found its way into Fashion Faceoff. Christina adds some drama to the scarlet Izmaylova number with shoulder-grazing danglers and a severe topknot, but Jennifer softens hers with a messy fishtail and low-key accessories.
65 of 65
PIPER VS. MIRANDA
Perhaps this sheer Michael Grant turtleneck blouse with billowy sleeves came with instructions: Dry clean only and wear only while posing with both hands on hips.
WATCH AND SHOP: Where Has This Jewelry Armoire Been All Our Lives?