1 of 68
BETHENNY VS. MARIA
This super-flattering Tees by Tina shirt looks adorable on the Skinnygirl mogul with a cardi, pendant and straw hat, and just as cute on the TV host en route to a workout.
2 of 68
JESSICA VS. FERGIE
Atten-tion! We stand and salute both of these stars for styling this brass-button Salvatore Ferragamo military coat two different ways. opts for buttoned-up and prim, while goes loose and funky.
3 of 68
CARLY VS. MARIA
Both stars pair their palm-print Lisa Ho blazer with shorts, though the singer picks a wild pair to go with her basic shoes, and the tennis star keeps her shorts on the mild side and opts for fabulous footwear instead.
4 of 68
VANESSA VS. ALESSANDRA
Both brunette babes bare a serious amount of skin in this For Love & Lemons dress with a racy crochet panel – though gives hers a little extra edge with chunky booties.
5 of 68
RIHANNA VS. STELLA
We typically wear our PJs with slippers and a messy bun, but then again, we aren’t international and our PJs aren’t by Stella McCartney.
6 of 68
TAYLOR VS. VICTORIA
This cat-face French Connection sweater gets the retro treatment (with pearls and bow-topped kitten heels) on , while the Nickelodeon star gives hers a modern take in gray skinnies and stilettos.
7 of 68
LILY VS. MIRANDA
Two women who were born to wear leather leggings (when they’re not strutting down the Victoria’s Secret catwalk in their underwear, that is) each put their own twist on this Helmut Lang style.
8 of 68
RUMER VS. ZENDAYA
daughter wears the full-skirted Alice + Olivia design with ombré locks and sexy sandals, while the Disney star looks straight out of a ’60s girl group with her bob and bright lips.
9 of 68
ANNE VS. SALMA
Both stunning actresses get fringe benefits from their kicky Stella McCartney party dresses. Is it better with a pretty pixie and patent heels or a fancy updo and stacked pumps?
10 of 68
ZOË VS. OLIVIA
How cute does this sunny yellow Old Navy peacoat look with Zoë’s tomboyish cropped cargos and Olivia’s leather leggings? Get in on the Faceoff by ordering the for just $27.50!
11 of 68
KATY VS. ANNASOPHIA
sticks to basics when styling her printed Joe’s jeans, adding all-black accessories. AnnaSophia opts for more advanced techniques, adding a striped sweater and polka-dot scarf (Carrie Bradshaw would be proud!).
12 of 68
LIV VS. ALEXIS
If you’re always on the hunt for day-to-night outfit tips, look no further. The two actresses wear the same Beckley by Melissa top, but Liv wears hers around town with jeans and a crossbody, while Alexis makes hers party-ready with dramatic earrings and cute heels.
13 of 68
KRISTEN VS. KELLY
Two reality stars from opposite coasts in the same Olcay Gulsen top. But do you like it with L.A.-inspired loose shorts and simple heels, or Kelly’s New York-appropriate monochromatic pants and shoes?
14 of 68
EMILY VS. PIPPA
Two brunette British beauties, two different takes on this Roksanda Ilincic dress. The wears the red version with nude booties and the goes subdued in burgundy with basic pumps.
15 of 68
EMMY VS. DIANNA
You could play this Ani Lee dress simple and girlie, as Emmy does with dainty flats, or you could follow Dianna’s lead and add some quirky appeal via Oxfords, ankle socks and a polka-dot print bag.
16 of 68
17 of 68
SELITA VS. HILARY
And then there are those Faceoffs where you have to choose between two Victoria’s Secret models. Both stunners show off their enviable rear views in the backless Monika Chiang dress and sky-high heels.
18 of 68
KRISTEN VS. CARRIE
Got a cute leather jacket, like the Express one, $88, owned by and ? Two new ways to wear it: over a flowy dress or with short-shorts and patterned tights.
19 of 68
JENNIFER VS. JESSICA
Let’s be honest: Sundance is really about who can make a puffy coat look cutest. This year, the competition is stiff with and wearing different colors of the same $348 Coach jacket.
20 of 68
DIANE VS. KIM
Both Diane and Kim pair the high-slit, high-collar Altuzarra dress with ankle-strap heels and smoky eyes. Unsurprisingly, the ensembles look completely different on them.
21 of 68
ALI VS. STACY
Proof that even starlets know how to pinch pennies: They rent the same Nanette Lepore dress ($65 at Rent the Runway) and put their own spin on the dainty style.
22 of 68
KRYSTEN VS. KELLY
Further evidence that accessories make all the difference: A belt and lace-up heels transform Krysten’s Robert Rodriguez coat into a sexy dress, while Kelly’s simple boots and scarf give it more of a classic feel.
23 of 68
KELLY VS. CATT
Do you prefer this Aryn K. jumpsuit when worn full-force in a pumpkin hue with the matching jacket, as seen on Kelly? Or is Catt’s understated take on the black version more your speed?
24 of 68
KRISTEN VS. CAMERON
We love how both and play up the slouchy menswear vibe and black-and-white palette of their A.L.C. pants. So it comes down to which star’s choice of footwear makes her a shoe-in for the Faceoff crown.
25 of 68
EVA VS. JESSICA
Shredded heat: and both look smokin’ in their strategically torn StyleStalker sweaters no matter the weather.
26 of 68
CATT VS. OLIVIA
Try to look past the distracting sheer bodice on this plunging For Love & Lemons number to decide whose accessories – Catt’s eye-popping silver picks or Olivia’s simple black ones – really perfect the printed mini.
27 of 68
SHAILENE VS. DIANE
There are nearly three decades between these two actresses, but somehow, the body-skimming dusty rose Dolce & Gabbana sheath looks perfectly age-appropriate on both of them.
28 of 68
BUSY VS. KALEY
These multicolor sequin Rebecca Minkoff pants make quite a statement on their own, as Busy proves. Though when worn as part of a full suit, as seen on Kaley, the impact is quadrupled.
29 of 68
JENNIFER VS. MARIAH
It’s not quite Brenda vs. Kelly in the same Spring Dance dress, but the and the do their best impression of those 90210 divas in a white-bow-topped Valentino column.
30 of 68
CHARLIZE VS. LINDSAY
Another pair of stars whom we never would have put in the same dress: the Oscar-winning (in strappy sandals) and the Liz and Dick (wearing see-through booties), both in sheer-paneled Dion Lee.
31 of 68
KELLY VS. ERIKA
From the neck down, both stars seem to have similar thoughts on how to accessorize this Marc Jacobs mini. From the neck up, though, their choices could not be more different.
32 of 68
JENNA VS. ANNALYNNE
We have a feeling that, after seeing how cute these two actresses look In their cozy Heartloom fringe cardigan, a number of our readers will want to get in on the Faceoff with the same sweater.
33 of 68
CAMILA VS. NATASHA
This green cutout Issa dress is going to bring the drama no matter who wears it, but the gown definitely has a different effect with Camila’s long, dark hair than with Natasha’s chunky golden cuffs.
34 of 68
KRISTIN VS. TAYLOR
You know considers herself the “Charlotte” of her friend group, so it’s no surprise she and the Sex and the City actress both went for the same polished Kate Spade New York dress with its puffed sleeves and a prim silhouette.
35 of 68
OLIVIA VS. BRIDGET
We’ve said it a thousand times, but stars keep proving our point: A tailored black blazer, like this Rachel Zoe Collection one, pairs well with everything – from Olivia’s tall boots and pink clutch to Bridget’s bell-bottom suit.
36 of 68
REESE VS. STACY
What do these two have in common besides super-successful significant others? A love of a good bargain. They pair their Gap pullovers with jeans, though goes sporty in lace-ups while Stacy accessories with elegant flats.
37 of 68
JANUARY VS. SELMA
We all know that Jordan Catalano wins the plaid button-down Fashion Faceoff, but if we take him out of the running, who wins? January, who wears the Splendid top with skinny jeans, or Selma, who pairs it with beaten-up boyfriend denim?
38 of 68
SHAY VS. ASHLEY
Not only do the Pretty Little Liars costars own the same pair of Monika Chiang leather leggings, but they wore them out on the same night to the same ABC Family event.
39 of 68
GWYNETH VS. KERRY
What looks great with a short-sleeve cream Wes Gordon sweater? According to these two stars, the answer is a flouncy mini, though the opts for a white skirt and the Scandal actress goes for black leather.
40 of 68
HANNAH VS. CARMEN
Both ladies have the killer curves required to wear this high-slit, strapless Rafael Cennamo gown. So, really, it comes down to whether you’re on team blue or team red.
41 of 68
JULIANNE VS. KHLOé
Apparently this shocking shade isn’t as hard to pull off as we thought. Two stars with different skin tones, different hair colors and different body types look pretty amazing in their neon KaufmanFranco gowns.
42 of 68
EMMY VS. CHARLIZE
Emmy answers the call of the wild by pairing her zebra-motif Madewell sweater with a black mini and booties, while does it with zipper-embellished jeans.
43 of 68
SARAH JESSICA VS. JESSICA
Two more ladies giving in to their animal instincts: keeps her spotted Current/Elliot top casual with distressed boyfriend jeans, flats and slouchy outerwear, but throws hers on with black skinnies and wedge sneakers.
44 of 68
RIHANNA VS. NICOLE
The Tom Ford gown selected for the Met Gala may be the most demure look she’s ever picked out. But the same dress at cocktail length on is one of the more avant-garde things she’s worn.
45 of 68
46 of 68
47 of 68
KOURTNEY VS. JENNIFER
Yes, that’s right, we’re asking who wears her leather turtleneck bodysuit best. goes girlie and plays it sleek. Get your own (it’s Monika Chiang) for a cool $795.
48 of 68
PIPPA VS. JAYMA
We wouldn’t blame Jayma if she ran out and bought this Paper London “Rayleigh” dress after seeing it on last year. But did she improve on the look by adding an air tie?
49 of 68
ALICIA VS. GWYNETH
There are very few women who could pull off this obliques-baring, backless Michael Kors number, but and are among the select group.
50 of 68
ELIZABETH VS. ASHLEE
In the market for a chic, well-priced leather pencil skirt? Why not get in on the fashion faceoff with the two stars, who sport ASOS’s $152.60 number with very different looks.
51 of 68
MILA VS. ZOË
and are clearly both dog people. They wear matching Madewell tees featuring nautical stripes and cute pooches (on sale for $35.99) with jeans and comfy shoes.
52 of 68
SOPHIA VS. ANNE
The 194t sweatshirt looks as cute with Sophia’s polka-dot pants, bright purse and heels as it does with the jean shorts. It’s official: This is one seriously versatile top.
53 of 68
MISCHA VS. MIRANDA
This Juicy Couture “Olivia” coat makes quite a statement on its own – but do you prefer it worn over a black dress and tights or a mini and booties?
54 of 68
EMMA VS. FREIDA
Same styling ideas, very different results. wears her Burberry bustier with forest green sequins and black pumps, while Freida opts for pants and sandals in the same hues.
55 of 68
CARRIE VS. ALLISON
The goes all-out with an updo, sparkly jewels and silver sandals, while the Girls actress attempts to downplay the princessy vibe of her Alice + Olivia dress with sideswept waves and simple heels.
56 of 68
ZOOEY VS. JESSICA
Two of Hollywood’s caped crusaders seem to be on the same wavelength, choosing identical Leon Max capes for their N.Y.C. adventures.
57 of 68
REESE VS. JESSICA
Think a crewneck sweater is a snooze? (wearing her Autumn Cashmere number over a button-up and riding boots) and (who tops hers with a fuzzy vest) prove otherwise.
58 of 68
RUMER VS. LINDSAY
Two stars who aren’t afraid to be bold. They show off their midriffs in the same teal Boulee dress, though Rumer’s approach is more daytime-appropriate and styles hers for an evening out.
59 of 68
EMILY VS. KATY
We adored this Alexander McQueen gown when we saw it on last year, so we’re psyched that wore it again, giving us another chance to admire the gorgeous hue and jeweled collar.
60 of 68
JESSICA VS. ELISABETH
Great Hollywood minds think alike. Both actresses wear their Dolce & Gabbana lace LBDs with pointed pumps, down ‘dos and understated makeup.
61 of 68
THANDIE VS. JULIANNE
The British actress opts for the ultra-feminine, sheer Temperley London dress in powder blue, while the Safe Haven picks the same dress in a vibrant tangerine shade.
62 of 68
ALESSANDRA VS. VANESSA
This For Love & Lemons maxi works equally well at a red carpet event (on the supermodel) as it does when layered with boho accessories (on the ).
63 of 68
KAT VS. JAMIE
Anyone else humming “Beat It” right now? The two women channel the King of Pop in their glossy red Armani Exchange puffers (the Vampire Diaries star in leather leggings and the Hangover actress in workout gear).
64 of 68
ALICIA VS. MILEY
On , this zip-up, cut-out halter is sort of edgy and fashion-forward. On , the identical top has us all doing alarmed double takes.
65 of 68
SIENNA VS. CATHERINE
Lace! Fringe! Décolletage! This Emilio Pucci number has it all. It’s up to you to decide who braves the many elements best.
66 of 68
JENNA VS. KATY
We’re all coveting this Rodarte coat, but only Jenna and have gotten their hands on it so far. The 1600 Penn star gives hers the first lady treatment, while the singer wears hers with boho-glam accessories.
67 of 68
JENNY VS. KRISTIN
We told you capes are in, and here’s further proof: The two blondes each wear the same Dressbarn cape to run errands in N.Y.C.
68 of 68
STEPHANIE VS. ALANIS
Hollywood’s favorite sweater gets a few more celeb fans: the Hills alumna, who picks the navy version, and the singer, who travels in gray.
Elsa Pataky Shows Off Her Killer Six-Pack Abs in a Bikini During Spain Vacation
Christina Aguilera Returns to Her Blonde Bombshell Vibes with New Hair Color
Let Kate Hudson Inspire You to Rock a Copper Lip this Fall - Here's How to Nail the Look
What’s It Like To Work With Jennifer Lopez’s Stylist? These Bloggers Got the Chance of a Lifetime!
Ariel Winter Shares Her Butt Contouring Process on Instagram
15 Rules for Finding the Perfect Wedding Dress