1 of 62
PARMINDER VS. SHAY
What do these brunette beauties have in common? A shared love of a good bargain, apparently: Their bright blue Aryn. K dresses cost just $108!
2 of 62
KRYSTEN VS. ALLISON
This Alice + Olivia dress packs a major punch – both on the Don’t Trust the B star, who increases the impact with an updo and cobalt heels, and on the Girls actress, who plays it cool with loose locks and basic heels.
3 of 62
PARIS VS. JANA
We’re totally digging this color-block halter from Chelsea Flower, though we don’t know if we prefer the socialite’s hippie-chic styling or the singer’s laid-back, beachy vibe.
4 of 62
JESSICA VS. KERRY
This subtly striped Dior dress looks so different in the two color options that we almost didn’t realize it’s the same design. wears the white version with neutral makeup, and Kerry looks girlie and sweet in the pink-and-red one.
5 of 62
KEIRA VS. REESE
Summer is winding down (tear), but here’s visual proof of how a warm-weather dress (in this case, a floral Wren creation) can easily transition into fall. has “Labor Day BBQ” written all over it, but additions (a pair of tights and a black blazer) make it perfect for chilly days.
6 of 62
ZOË VS. ANNE
shows off the Hollywood way of wearing her AG Adriano Goldschmied jean shorts (with a designer top and a coordinating handbag), but offers up more accessible styling, adding a tee and flats.
7 of 62
LANA VS. SELENA
Looking to add some may-jah drama to a simple, high-slit maxi? You could take a tip from Lana, who adds a fur coat and a white bag to her Ella Moss dress. Or you could follow lead and add a few choice accessories.
8 of 62
HOLLAND VS. NIKKI
Who knew high-waist, blousy blush shorts could be so versatile? Holland wears her Finders Keepers pair with a tucked-in emerald top and leopard heels, and Nikki embraces the peplum trend along with slightly edgy neutral accessories.
9 of 62
NICOLE VS. HAYDEN
We don’t know which version of this $143 is cuter: the mustard one seen on with appropriately edgy shoes, or the baby blue one wears with girlie heels.
10 of 62
ANNE VS. KATIE
The Madewell “Songbird” dress is a summer staple for the two stars, though belts hers and adds colorful flats instead of keeping it simple and tomboyish as does.
11 of 62
JESSICA VS. KRISTIN
To rock leopard-print, neon-airbrushed jeans (like these ones, $248), a certain amount of fearless fashion sense is required – which both and Kristin have in spades.
12 of 62
HANNAH VS. ASHLEY
In the battle of the New Girl vs. the Pretty Little Liar, which small screener comes out on top? Both actresses let their Cengiz Abazoglu dress take center stage and keep the rest of their looks understated.
13 of 62
JENNIFER VS. JENNIFER
If you think and look amazing from the front in their curve-hugging Tom Ford dresses, you should see the frock’s killer back view.
14 of 62
CHRISTINA VS. KHLOé
Two curvy girls show off their sexy shapes in the same Rebecca Taylor faux-wrap dress (), each choosing different accessories to create different looks.
15 of 62
SELMA VS. ALI
Splendid’s breezy $118 dress is a favorite of Hollywood moms like these two stars, who each put her own spin on the printed tank style.
16 of 62
ASHLEE VS. EMMA
Does this sweater have magical powers or something? Because no fewer than a dozen celebs have been spotted in different shades of the starry Wildfox creation, including and Emma, who both team the $220 with jeans.
17 of 62
CAROLINE VS. DIANNA
We’re not surprised that these two blonde beauties couldn’t resist a floral Tracy Reese for Anthropologie dress (a similar style is still available on ). The Disney actress chooses simple accessories, while the Glee star adds slightly edgy ones.
18 of 62
KIM VS. ANNE
Of course wears her $184 with those leather leggings. And we’re also not surprised to see the pairs hers with hipster-approved jean shorts and low-key flats.
19 of 62
EMILY VS. NAOMIE
In peach, with pink lips and girlie heels, this Marios Schwab dress is sugary sweet on Emily. In black, with smoky eyes and glam sandals, the same dress is smokin’ hot on Skyfall star Naomie.
20 of 62
CHRISTA VS. HEIDI
And you thought that super-sexy bodysuit from your Halloween couldn t be worn again! Christa gives her Dress the Population onesie, $89, a boho spin with a knitted shawl and hat, while Heidi adds hot pants (natch) to hers.
21 of 62
KEKE VS. ANNA
Already on the hunt for a holiday dress that will take you from work to a party? This Ted Baker Edella dress, $295, will do the trick: Whether in black or yellow, the embellished collar and fitted silhouette is perfect for a number of festive occasions.
22 of 62
JESSICA VS. KATY
And you thought jean jackets couldn’t get any comfier and more relaxed. and prove they can with the Jet by John Eshaya , $216, seen here over two very different looks.
23 of 62
ZOË VS. SARAH JESSICA
You may typically wear your favorite oversize sweater like Zoë does (with a tee and jeans), but we also like dressy take on the same Ella Moss cardigan: She belts it and adds sexy snakeskin heels.
24 of 62
ASHLEY VS. MARIA
Both ladies have similar styling ideas for this belted Michael Kors sheath (loose locks, minimal accessories) – but their instincts vary when it comes to footwear: Ashley goes for chunky sandals and Maria selects peep-toe pumps.
25 of 62
EVA VS. KARLIE
The puts her signature va-va-voom spin (skyscraper heels and a head-turning updo) on this slashed Emilio Pucci gown, while the model somehow makes it look more low-key thanks to messy locks.
26 of 62
PADMA VS. KRYSTEN
How to wear your favorite floral dress all year long: When it’s warm out, do as Padma does to her Erin by Erin Fetherston mini and add cool sandals and delicate jewels. Then get that frock ready for fall with a leather jacket and lace-up heels, as seen on Krysten.
27 of 62
EMILY VS. NIKKI
For Emily, this Dior dress is red-carpet worthy when paired with orange heels. Nikki prefers to toss it on with platform pumps for a day of shopping.
28 of 62
HEIDI VS. TERI
The fit of these Thomas Wylde dresses is so different on the two women that we almost didn’t notice they’re sporting the same silky number.
29 of 62
JESSICA VS. KATE
We’d like to raid both of their closets so it’s no surprise that the stars are wearing the same adorable Heartloom. Do you prefer it under a denim vest or styled with nothing but jewelry?
30 of 62
JENNA VS. AUTUMN
The two young actresses think pink in Naven: The Glee cast member goes funky with black accessories and red lips, while the Last Resort starlet lets the neon hue speak for itself.
31 of 62
KATY VS. ASHLEE
gives her Temperley London gown the hippie-chic treatment by letting it casually hang off one shoulder, but plays it straight with minimal accessories.
32 of 62
KERRY VS. BRITNEY
The two ladies style Stella McCartney’s boldly printed sheath similarly (letting the dress speak for itself), but they show just how unique the same frock can look on different body types.
33 of 62
MILEY VS. KATY
Stumped on how to wear your flowery kimono (inspired by these ladies’ Lovers + Friends style)? Why not go full-on hippie with flares and round shades, like , or try it with skinnies and wedges, like ?
34 of 62
KRYSTEN VS. HEIDI
Both the actress and the pay homage to a mall staple in their $29.90 Express Ikat-print tees, wearing them with ponies and chic shades for a casually cute around-town look.
35 of 62
JORDIN VS. POPPY
Who could resist this much sparkle? Apparently not the or the Unforgettable actress, who both pick Kevan Hall’s glittering tiered dress for red carpet events.
36 of 62
EMILY VS. JESS
This lace Alice + Olivia number is so killer that we’d really like to nab it for ourselves and get in on this faceoff.
37 of 62
GINNIFER VS. EVA
In vivid orange, this Monique Lhuillier gown is cheerful and striking; in black, it’s dramatic and elegant. Editors here are split so we need you to help us break the tie!
38 of 62
JESSICA VS. MICHELLE
and just gave us one very good reason to shop the Narciso Rodriguez for DesigNation collection at Kohl’s (launching Nov. 7): these printed, tuxedo-stripe pants from the line, which they each style uniquely.
39 of 62
JESSICA VS. HALLE
We love fall weather and all the accompanying autumnal hues. A slouchy pumpkin-colored Feel the Piece sweater looks as cute with a blazer and leopard flats (on ) as it does with a chill weekend look (on ).
40 of 62
AUBREY VS. LESLIE
Two funny ladies take on the same serious Rodarte dress. Both opt for slicked-back dos, but the footwear choices vary in a big way.
41 of 62
ASHLEY VS. MARIA
picks a Kymerah dress with a sheer coral overlay, while Maria wears her printed dress without – but both look equally California-chic.
42 of 62
SOPHIA VS. KRISTIN
This Olcay Gulsen mini, spotted on in olive and in white, is saucy from the front, but it’s the daring rear view that really makes the dress special.
43 of 62
EMMY VS. ZENDAYA
This sweet Kate Spade New York sheath can be worn casually, with flat sandals and undone locks (like Emmy Rossum) or dressed up with colorful heels, as seen on the Disney star.
44 of 62
REBECCA VS. KIMORA
Two tall, gorgeous models in the same head-turning Issa London mini? This decision is going to be a toughie – and it all comes down to the accessories.
45 of 62
EVA VS. OLIVIA
The same Kate Spade New York peplum top that sexes up with leather hot pants and platform heels looks girlie on Olivia when tucked into a pleated midi skirt.
46 of 62
KATIE VS. JANE
designed this Holmes & Yang swiss-dot party dress – but is Suburgatory star Jane a better model for the look?
47 of 62
NICKY VS. CHARLIZE
Nicky gives her slinky black Gold Hawk cami the weekend treatment with short-shorts and feline accessories. makes it office-appropriate with a blazer and sleek skinnies.
48 of 62
SARAH VS. BELLA
Which TV teen earns high marks for her styling: Sarah, in a red Ted Baker dress, nude heels and pendant necklace, or Bella, who adds contrasting booties and bangles to her blue version?
49 of 62
LAUREN VS. DIANNA
The two California blondes were both born to wear this sunflower-print Alice + Olivia dress. So it just depends on whether you prefer the look with girlie Mary Janes or matchy-matchy pumps.
50 of 62
LESLIE VS. BLAKE
Leslie and go head-to-head in this Twelfth Street by Cynthia Vincent blazer, but we already know the true winner of this Fashion Faceoff: our Denim Girl!
51 of 62
KIMORA VS. CHRISTINA
These very different stars had surprisingly similar styling ideas for their Black Halo dresses: They add specs and cap-toe pumps to make the frock carpet-ready in a sexy librarian sort of way.
52 of 62
HEIDI VS. JENNIFER
What do you reach for if you have a smoking hot figure and a red carpet event? Apparently, this glam Versace mini.
53 of 62
KRISTEN VS. LILY
Unsurprisingly, gives this $650 AllSaints leather jacket a bit of an edge, while the Mirror Mirror star injects some sweetness into hers with harem pants and ballet flats.
54 of 62
JAMIE-LYNN VS. LAUREN
For those of you still doubting the transformative power of a belt: Jamie-Lynn’s wide embellished one makes her Erin by Erin Fetherston mini seem like a totally different dress than rose version, which she wears with a slender nude cincher.
55 of 62
EMMA VS. RUMER
A statement necklace and ankle boots make Emma’s A/X Armani Exchange dress ($119 here) party-ready, and an unzipped neckline and classic pumps make Rumer’s perfect for an elegant night at the theater.
56 of 62
TIFFANI VS. MELANIE
Both actresses will get plenty of mileage out of these pretty Pamella Roland shifts: In addition to the two adorable ways to style it seen here, we can picture the number with tights, booties and a blazer.
57 of 62
JENNA VS. ASHLEE
Got a bold blazer in your closet that you’re not sure how to style? These two ladies are here to help. We love how both of them wear the Rebecca Minkoff blazer – with a teeny mini or layered necklaces and skinnies.
58 of 62
GWEN VS. KRISTEN
Though these two ladies have distinctly different styles, they both nabbed A.L.C.’s white-waistband cropped pants, which jazzes up with yellow heels and a denim vest, and makes look laid-back and sexy.
59 of 62
HALLE VS. DITA
We don’t envy you the task of choosing which bombshell brunette looks best in her square-neckline Roland Mouret party dress – both were born to wear the glam retro style.
60 of 62
JAIME VS. ZOË
Looking pretty and patriotic in their red, white and blue, the two stars choose to pair their A/X Armani Exchange skinny jeans with basic tops and classic shoes.
61 of 62
BLAKE VS. KATIE
Just because they have A-list budgets doesn’t mean and can’t appreciate a great deal. They both wear their $29.50 Old Navy Rockstar skinnies with feminine tops and great shoes.
62 of 62
ISLA VS. JANUARY
If we owned this Two by Vince Camuto blouse, $79, we d wear it in these two ways: tucked into a fitted skirt with nude heels for a dressed-up look and with cropped jeans and wedge heels for running errands.