Here at PEOPLE StyleWatch, we’re taking it upon ourselves to answer the really tough beauty questions. After definitively choosing whether hot pink lips or nude gloss is sexier, we decided to take on eye makeup.
Two looks are particularly big on the red carpet now: smoky eyes and winged liner. And while we’re big fans of both, we’d guess the guys in our life have a particular favorite.
In the video above, watch senior editor Zoë Ruderman and beauty director Andrea Lavinthal debate which look men like most, then get tips on how to create the perfect sexy eye yourself.
Tell us: Which do you prefer for a night out?