1 of 18
Shannon O’Donnell (Sodonnell) sent us this photo of Finnegan dressed as a witch last Halloween. Finnegan looks like she has zero interest in leaving her perch on the porch!
2 of 18
Boo! It’s the Wicked Witch of Times Square! Yorkshire terrier Petey dressed up as the Wicked Witch of the West for the Fifth Annual Times Square Dog Day Masquerade. Too bad he’s just too cute to be scary!
3 of 18
GEORGE CLOONEY AND STELLA
These costumes are fitting! Pug George Clooney has real fangs, so mom Tina Calhoun dressed him up as a vampire, while her parents’ dog, Stella, is under a pointy hat since – yikes! – she “is a little witch sometimes.”
4 of 18
Sensitive dog Duchess posed for this photo while mom Monica Hall laughed! She tells PEOPLE.com, “I laughed so hard that when I was done, she stuck her head under the sofa and wouldn’t look at me again.”
5 of 18
Michelle Wolfskill (bellalamb613) named her pug Elphaba after a witch in the musical Wicked, so it was only appropriate to dress Elphie up as a witch for her first Halloween! Wolfskill tells us that Elphie “liked the clothes, but she wasn’t so sure about that hat.”
6 of 18
She casts a spell! Ally Jerchau’s pet pup Daisy looks has quite a sophisticated pose in her spider-web cape and purple-striped hat.
7 of 18
Michelle Dieffenbacher tells PEOPLE.com that her tuxedo cat Luna is little, but “don’t let her pint-size stature fool you! She can take on her 14-lb. tabby cat brother any day – and has been known to throw some hexes his way!”
8 of 18
My, what a bewitching gaze! Pomeranian Ivanka glammed it up in this Halloween photo for mom Patricia Holtz (TRICIA817).
9 of 18
Contrary to what most cats seem to experience with costumes, Maui doesn’t mind dressing up, says owner Brian Goodrich.
10 of 18
Amber Friedan’s Boston terrier was well-behaved enough to pose for this photo, “but was pretty humiliated that he had to get dressed up.”
11 of 18
Kim Boocher (Doggone) dressed her 2-year-old Yorkie, Sasha, as the Good Witch of the South. This little sweetie couldn’t be anything but a good witch!
12 of 18
Which is the Witch? They both are! And apparently they’re related! Linda Polston (lindasmith68) says that “Tipper the witch and his old grandmother witch are helping each other to brew up a recipe that will knock your silly socks off. Beware, or we will get you!”
13 of 18
Mom Jennifer Pileggi (JeniiBabiix3) dressed her Pomeranian Mini as a candy corn witch, complete with tutu, ruffled sleeves, and a candy corn hat! Now that’s good enough to eat.
14 of 18
We’ve got one from the west and one from the south, and here is the Good Witch from the North! Meet Little Bit, the pal of Robin Wood (littlebitwood). Check out her profile for a look at Little Bit as a pumpkin too!
15 of 18
What a fright! Sheila Avilla’s (scary706) pug Deja has the perfect witchy gaze for this Halloween costume!
16 of 18
This one rides around on a pumpkin instead of a broom! Mom Charlotte Gamble (charg05) tells us that her dog Georgia was picking out her pumpkin in this photo.
17 of 18
Trish Anderson (poohstr) writes on her profile that she has made several outfits for her Pekingese, Hope. She makes a satiny striped number work in this glamour shot!
18 of 18
Lidia Carter (tigerlady14) tells us that her dog Shawnee is dressed as the black widow witch. Shawnee says, “Don’t do me wrong because I will cast a mean spell on you of hugs and kisses.” Now that’s a punishment we’ll take!